Sildenafil vs. Tadalafil: Navigating Your Sexual Health Treatment Options

Sildenafil vs Tadalafil

CONTENT WARNING: We wanted to let you know ahead of time that we make several references to reproductive body parts and processes below. For some folks, this can trigger dysphoria, so just FYI, before you continue reading.

Starting estrogen and/or testosterone blockers as part of gender-affirming hormone therapy (GAHT) can bring about significant changes in sexual function due to shifts in hormone levels. Specifically, when estrogen levels increase, and testosterone levels decrease, there can be noticeable effects on the body’s erectile tissue and the way blood flows to this area. For some trans and nonbinary folks, this adjustment is a welcomed part of gender transition, helping their physical appearance and bodily functions align more closely with their gender identity.

However, not everyone undergoing GAHT desires these changes, especially if you wish to maintain sexual function. It’s important to understand that these modifications in sexual function are a natural response to the shifting balance of hormones in the body. Testosterone, for instance, plays a key role in the development and maintenance of erectile tissue structure and in regulating blood flow to this area. When its levels drop, changes in sexual function can occur. This doesn’t mean that erectile function will be lost entirely, but it might change in ways that are unexpected or undesired for some individuals. These changes may lead some to seek solutions to maintain sexual function. Medications like sildenafil (Viagra) and tadalafil (Cialis) can be valuable options for transgender folks interested in addressing these concerns. 

Table of Contents

How sildenafil and tadalafil can help

Sildenafil and tadalafil are known in the medical community as phosphodiesterase type 5 (PDE5) inhibitors, a term that might sound complex but refers to their ability to boost blood flow to specific areas of the body, including erectile tissue. When a person feels sexually excited, these medications can enhance the natural process, making it easier to achieve and maintain an erection. This effect is especially useful for those who might experience changes in sexual function due to hormone therapy as part of their gender transition.

Understanding how these medications work can demystify their role in maintaining sexual health. When sexually stimulated, the body normally increases blood flow to erectile tissue. What sildenafil and tadalafil do is inhibit (or block) a specific enzyme in your body, leading to an increased blood flow in the areas needed for erection. However, it’s crucial to emphasize that they don’t create sexual arousal on their own. They work with your body’s natural response to sexual stimulation, making them a supportive tool rather than a standalone solution.

Both medications are similar in their purpose but differ in duration and flexibility. This means that you can choose between them based on their lifestyle and how you prefer to engage in sexual activity. This choice allows for a tailored approach to sexual health, accommodating the unique needs of individuals undergoing hormone therapy. By offering an option to enhance sexual function, sildenafil and tadalafil provide a means to address one of the potential concerns related to hormone-induced changes, enabling you to maintain aspects of your sexual health according to your preferences.

Deciding between sildenafil and tadalafil

Choosing the right medication to support erectile function while undergoing hormone therapy is a personal decision that hinges on several factors unique to each individual’s lifestyle and sexual activity patterns. Both sildenafil and tadalafil offer promising benefits, but understanding the differences in how they work and their effects on the body can help in making an informed choice.

Sildenafil is known for its quick action, usually taking effect within 30 to 60 minutes of ingestion, making it a suitable option for those who prefer or require more flexibility around the timing of sexual activities. This characteristic makes it an appealing choice for spontaneous encounters, as it doesn’t require daily administration.

On the other hand, tadalafil offers a different kind of convenience and flexibility. This medication can be taken as needed, or daily.  With the option to take it as a daily medication, tadalafil allows for a readiness that does not need to be planned around sexual activity. This can be particularly appealing for individuals who desire a less scheduled approach to their sexual experiences, providing the freedom to engage in sexual activities more spontaneously without the need to pre-plan medication timing.

The decision between sildenafil and tadalafil also involves considering how frequently one anticipates engaging in sexual activity. For those with less frequent sexual activities, sildenafil may be more cost-effective and practical. Conversely, for individuals who engage in sexual activities more regularly or prefer the assurance of being ready at any time, tadalafil’s daily dosing might offer an unmatched advantage.

Ultimately, the choice between these two medications should be guided by a discussion with a healthcare provider, taking into account the specifics of one’s sexual lifestyle, the desired flexibility in sexual planning, and any potential interactions with other medications being taken as part of one’s gender-affirming hormone therapy. This personalized approach ensures that the decision not only aligns with the individual’s sexual health goals but also integrates seamlessly into their overall journey of transitioning.

Tips for talking to your healthcare provider

Navigating conversations with your healthcare provider about sexual health can feel daunting, but it’s a critical step in ensuring your treatment aligns with your needs and lifestyle. Here are some strategies to make these discussions more productive and less stressful:

Prepare Your Questions. Before your appointment, jot down any concerns or queries you have. This might include questions about the differences between sildenafil and tadalafil, their potential side effects, or how they could fit into your gender-affirming hormone therapy regimen.

Be Candid About Your Sexual Activity. Sharing honest details about your sexual life, including frequency and spontaneity, can help your provider recommend the medication that best suits your lifestyle. There’s no need to feel embarrassed—your healthcare provider is there to assist you without judgment.

Discuss Your Whole Health Picture. Make sure to inform your provider about all medications and supplements you’re currently taking, not just those related to hormone therapy. This includes over-the-counter medicines, herbal supplements, and recreational substances, as they can all influence which sexual health medication is safest for you.

Express Your Concerns. If you have apprehensions about side effects, costs, or how a medication might interact with your hormone therapy, voice these concerns. Your provider can help you navigate these challenges and might suggest alternatives or adjustments to your treatment plan.

Request Information Resources. Ask if there are any brochures, reputable websites, or support groups they recommend for additional information. Sometimes, reading about others’ experiences or having more detailed information can ease uncertainties.

Follow-up Plan. Inquire about the best way to monitor your response to the medication, including how and when to report any side effects or issues. Knowing there’s a plan for follow-up can provide peace of mind.

It’s essential to recognize that the decision between sildenafil and tadalafil isn’t just about managing sexual function; it’s about empowering you to maintain control over your sexual health during your gender journey. By understanding the benefits, risks, and practical implications of each option, you’re better equipped to make a decision that aligns with your lifestyle, preferences, and overall well-being. Remember, your healthcare provider is there to support you through this process, offering guidance, answering questions, and ensuring that your sexual health needs are met in a way that honors your unique journey. With the right information and support, you can navigate your sexual health treatment options with confidence, enabling you to focus on what matters most: living authentically and comfortably as your true self.

In order to provide healthcare services to you and give you medically appropriate care, we are required to get a recent blood pressure reading. You can get your blood pressure read for free at many pharmacies, go to your primary care doctor, or you may purchase a blood pressure cuff online.